A baby who cries for hours, red in the face and drawing up their knees, looks as if they're in pain, and the urge to give them something is strong. The old cabinet holds fennel, peppermint and gripe water, first made in Nottingham in 1851 by a pharmacist called William Woodward. The modern pharmacy shelf has colic drops: simeticone, an anti-foaming agent meant to help bubbles of wind come together and pass, and lactase drops, an enzyme added to milk before a feed to break down its sugar.
What colic is
The NHS describes colic as a baby crying more than 3 hours a day, 3 days a week, for at least a week, while otherwise healthy. There's no obvious cause, and it should get better by around 3 or 4 months. I've looked at whether your diet is to blame in That curry will give the baby wind.
The drops on the shelf
The NHS is blunt: remedies such as anti-colic drops and herbal or probiotic supplements are sold in pharmacies and shops, but they're not recommended and there's no evidence they help colic.
A Cochrane review (a summary of all the good research on a question) in 2016 looked at 18 trials involving 1,014 babies. For simeticone, it found no difference from a dummy treatment in how many babies improved. A 2015 NHS prescribing bulletin found the evidence for lactase drops limited and mixed: one small, industry-funded trial showed less crying, and two others found no real difference.
Fennel, peppermint and gripe water
Herbs did a little better in that Cochrane review, cutting crying time compared with placebo. But the evidence was low quality and the results varied a lot, and the reviewers concluded herbal agents can't be recommended for babies with colic.
Woodward's original gripe water contained sodium bicarbonate, alcohol, dill oil, water and sugar. The alcohol has since gone, but some versions still list sugar. The same NHS bulletin said there are no clinical data to support gripe water for colic, and a 2015 study of 335 babies in India found it didn't prevent crying and was linked with vomiting and constipation.
There are safety points too:
- The NHS says breast milk is the only food or drink babies need in their first 6 months, with first infant formula the only alternative. It adds that baby and herbal drinks usually contain sugars and are not recommended.
- Fennel naturally contains estragole, and Swissmedic, the Swiss medicines regulator, says high amounts may be harmful. It advises fennel tea for children under 4 only after talking to a health professional, and not in pregnancy or breastfeeding.
- Never put peppermint oil, or anything containing menthol, on or near a baby. The European Medicines Agency says peppermint oil should not be used in children under 2, because menthol can cause reflex apnoea, a pause in breathing, and spasm of the voice box.
- The NHS also advises against spinal manipulation or cranial osteopathy for colic: there's little evidence it works, and it may hurt your baby.
If you've already bought something, check the pack and ask your pharmacist before using it.
What helps, and when to worry
The NHS suggests holding your baby upright during feeds, gently rocking them over your shoulder, using gentle white noise, and carrying on feeding as normal. It's hard going, and asking for support isn't a failure. Cry-sis runs a free helpline for parents of crying babies on 0800 448 0737, 9am to 10pm, 7 days a week.
Ring NHS 111 or see your GP if you're worried about your baby's crying. Go to A&E or ring 999 if your baby has a weak, high-pitched or continuous cry. The full list of warning signs is on Is this urgent?

What I think
I'd save your money. Cuddles, winding, a bit of white noise and time. Dull, I know, but safe, and colic does pass.
Chloe
Feeding not going to plan? I can come to you around Huntingdon, or talk by video anywhere in the UK.
Feeding supportSources
- NHS. Colic. NHS website, accessed 2026.
- Biagioli E and colleagues. Pain-relieving agents for infantile colic. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2016.
- PrescQIPP. Bulletin 99: Infantile colic. PrescQIPP, 2015.
- Dayton L. Gripe water. Australian Pharmacist, 2023, updated 2024.
- NHS. Drinks and cups for babies and young children. NHS website, accessed 2026.
- Swissmedic. Fennel tea for pregnant women, infants and children under 4 years. Swissmedic, 2024.
- European Medicines Agency. European Union herbal monograph on Mentha x piperita L., aetheroleum. EMA, 2020.
