Worried right now? Please don't wait for a reply from me. Is this urgent?
The Lunar MidwifeChloe Birt, Registered Midwife Gift vouchersBook

Home › Tales and truths › The medicine cabinet › Arnica, or paracetamol?

The medicine cabinet · No. 50

Arnica, or paracetamol?

Arnica is a favourite for bruising and soreness after birth. Here's what the research shows, and how it compares with paracetamol and ibuprofen if you're breastfeeding.

3 minute read

After birth, especially after stitches or an assisted birth, lots of women reach for a little tube of arnica tablets or a tub of arnica cream. Arnica is a flowering plant, and homeopathic arnica tablets are, as the NHS puts it, very watered-down mixtures. Here's how it compares with the painkillers your midwife is more likely to suggest.

What the arnica research shows

A UK survey of childbearing women, published in the British Journal of Midwifery in 2012, found 12% of those who replied had used homeopathic arnica, and most had possibly or probably not taken it in the way homeopaths themselves advise.

The research after birth is thin. A double-blind pilot study of 161 women, published in 1990, found no benefit from homeopathic arnica over a placebo. A small preliminary study in 2005 found women given arnica with another homeopathic remedy lost less blood than those on placebo, but it looked at blood counts, not bruising or pain, and it hasn't changed practice.

Outside birth, a 1998 systematic review of eight trials concluded that the claim that homeopathic arnica works better than a placebo was not based on sound trials. A 2021 review of trials after surgery found a small effect. More broadly, Australia's National Health and Medical Research Council concluded in 2015 that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective. NHS England stopped routine prescribing of homeopathy in 2017, saying there was no robust evidence to support it.

If you use arnica

  • Homeopathic tablets and cream. LactMed, the US government's database on medicines and breastfeeding, says homeopathic products and creams are usually safe while breastfeeding.
  • Never on broken skin. LactMed says arnica shouldn't be used on broken skin, so not on stitches or a tear. It can cause skin allergies, especially if you react to plants such as chamomile or dandelion.
  • Never as a herbal tea or tincture (a herbal extract in alcohol). Arnica taken by mouth as a herb contains toxic compounds. LactMed describes a 9-day-old baby who developed serious jaundice from broken-down red blood cells after the mother drank arnica tea.

What the pharmacy offers

The NHS says painkillers such as paracetamol can help after a tear and are safe while breastfeeding, and that ibuprofen is also considered safe while breastfeeding, though you should check with your doctor first. Aspirin isn't recommended, as it can pass to your baby through your milk.

The Breastfeeding Network's drugs in breastmilk factsheet adds that only a very small amount of paracetamol or ibuprofen passes into breastmilk, and that the two can be taken together. It says ibuprofen may not suit you if you've had a stomach ulcer or have asthma, and that products containing codeine are not recommended while breastfeeding, because codeine can pass to your baby and cause drowsiness or breathing problems.

Check the pack, read the leaflet, and if you're breastfeeding, the NHS says to check with a pharmacist, midwife or GP before you buy over-the-counter painkillers.

Simple comforts help too. The NHS suggests an ice pack or ice cubes wrapped in a towel, never directly on the skin, and bathing stitches every day. A Cochrane review (a summary of all the good research on a question) found very low certainty evidence that cooling may ease perineal pain in the first days.

When pain is a warning sign

Tell your GP, midwife or health visitor as soon as you can if your stitches or tear become red and swollen, leak pus or fluid, smell unusual, or keep hurting. The NHS says to tell them straight away if you have a high temperature with a tender tummy, sudden heavy bleeding, or chest pain or breathlessness. See Is this urgent?

If your recovery isn't going as you'd hoped, there's support on the Mothering page.

What I think

I'd go for paracetamol and an ice pack. They're tried and tested, and fine with breastfeeding. Ask your pharmacist what's right for you, and never drink arnica as a tea.

Chloe

Looking after you, too A recovery session covers your body, your sleep and your mood after the birth.

Recovery sessions

This is general information, not personal medical advice. Always check with your own pharmacist, midwife or GP before taking or stopping any medicine or remedy. If you're worried about yourself or your baby, see Is this urgent?

Sources

  1. Hofmeyr GJ, Piccioni V, Blauhof P. Postpartum homoeopathic Arnica montana: a potency-finding pilot study. British Journal of Clinical Practice, 1990.
  2. EBSCO Research Starters. Homeopathic remedies for labor and childbirth.
  3. Oberbaum M and colleagues. The effect of the homeopathic remedies Arnica montana and Bellis perennis on mild postpartum bleeding: preliminary results. Complementary Therapies in Medicine, 2005.
  4. Use of homeopathic Arnica among childbearing women: a survey. British Journal of Midwifery, 2012.
  5. Ernst E, Pittler MH. Efficacy of homeopathic arnica: a systematic review of placebo-controlled clinical trials. Archives of Surgery, 1998 (DARE summary).
  6. Gaertner K, Baumgartner S, Walach H. Is homeopathic Arnica effective for postoperative recovery? A meta-analysis. Frontiers in Surgery, 2021.
  7. CBC News. Homeopathy not effective for treating any condition, Australian report finds, 2015.
  8. The Pharmaceutical Journal. Homeopathy legal challenge fails, 2018.
  9. LactMed (Drugs and Lactation Database). Arnica. US National Library of Medicine, revised 2026 (via Drugs.com).
  10. NHS. Complementary and alternative medicine. NHS website, accessed 2026.
  11. NHS. Episiotomy and perineal tears. NHS website, accessed 2026.
  12. NHS. Your body after the birth. NHS website, accessed 2026.
  13. The Breastfeeding Network. Pain relief and breastfeeding (Drugs in Breastmilk factsheet). BfN, 2025.
  14. East CE and colleagues. Local cooling for relieving pain from perineal trauma sustained during childbirth. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2020.
Chloe Birt